MIDDLETON, WI — Foremost Farms USA announced that President and CEO Greg Schlafer officially stepped down from his role on April 11, 2025, concluding a transformative five-year tenure at the helm of the Midwest-based dairy cooperative. Schlafer cited a desire to “rest and recharge” before embarking on a new opportunity later this year. His departure marks the end of a pivotal chapter for Foremost Farms, during which the organization regained financial stability and modernized its operations.
Schlafer joined Foremost Farms in December 2019 amid financial challenges that had placed the cooperative under bank forbearance. Under his leadership, the organization transitioned to a position of lending group credibility. He spearheaded a comprehensive transformation strategy that included investments in personnel, infrastructure, and technology. Notably, Schlafer oversaw the establishment of a new headquarters in Middleton, Wisconsin, and implemented initiatives aimed at strengthening operational performance.
Reflecting on his tenure, Schlafer stated, “I was invited to Foremost Farms to restore a proud organization and membership, and I’m proud we’re back on the right path. Dairy is a challenging industry, unlike any other, and it has been an honor to work alongside talented people that value working as one team from the board room to the plant floors.”
In the wake of Schlafer’s departure, Foremost Farms appointed an interim leadership team and initiated a national search for a permanent successor. The cooperative emphasized its ongoing commitment to innovation and its farmer-owned operational model during this transition period.
On May 5, 2025, Foremost Farms announced the appointment of Brenda Dehart as the new President and CEO. Dehart, who previously served as the cooperative’s Chief Financial Officer, brings a wealth of experience in financial leadership and a deep understanding of the dairy industry. Her background includes executive roles at Edlong, Sensient Technologies, and Kerry Inc. Dehart holds an MBA from the University of Phoenix and a bachelor’s degree in finance from Concordia University Wisconsin. She also serves on the board of Female Strong Chicago, reflecting her commitment to leadership development and community engagement.
Dehart expressed her enthusiasm for her new role, stating, “I am deeply honored to lead this incredible organization. Foremost Farms has a proud heritage and a promising future, and I look forward to working side by side with our employees, members, and partners to create long-term value across the entire value chain.”
Schlafer’s departure from Foremost Farms does not mark the end of his career in the dairy industry. On April 16, 2025, Hilmar Cheese Company announced that Schlafer would become its next President and CEO, effective July 1, 2025. Hilmar, a leading cheese and whey manufacturer based in California, highlighted Schlafer’s extensive experience in the dairy sector and his track record of driving operational excellence. Jim Ahlem, Chairman of Hilmar’s Board, noted that Schlafer’s background aligns well with the company’s culture and strategic objectives.
Foremost Farms USA, representing hundreds of dairy farmer members across seven Midwest states, continues to be a significant player in the U.S. dairy industry. The cooperative’s recent leadership transition underscores its dedication to sustaining growth, embracing innovation, and delivering value to its members.
